Assisted-dying legislation advances in Parliament amid controversy over safeguards
- (0)

OTTAWA — The Liberal government’s proposed changes to Canada’s medical assistance in dying legislation have cleared an important parliamentary hurdle, despite continued opposition concerns over the adequacy of debate and protections for vulnerable Canadians.
Bill C-41 passed second reading in the House of Commons on November 17 by a vote of 225 to 89 and will now proceed to the Standing Committee on Justice and Human Rights.
The legislation would allow eligible Canadians suffering from serious and incurable conditions to make advance requests for medical assistance in dying before losing the capacity to provide consent.
The proposed provisions would apply under specific conditions and require participating provinces to establish their own legislative frameworks and safeguards.
The bill would also prevent the scheduled expansion of assisted-dying eligibility to individuals whose sole underlying medical condition is a mental illness.
That expansion is currently scheduled to take effect on March 17, 2027, unless Parliament adopts legislation extending or making permanent the exclusion.
Conservatives have expressed support for preventing the mental-illness expansion but have urged the government to separate that provision from the proposed advance-request system, arguing that the latter requires more extensive parliamentary scrutiny.
The Bloc Québécois has also criticized the government’s decision to limit debate on legislation addressing such sensitive questions.
Justice Minister Sean Fraser has defended the timetable, arguing that Parliament must act before the existing deadline while allowing further examination of the proposed safeguards at committee.
Under Bill C-41, two independent medical practitioners or nurse practitioners would have to confirm that an advance request satisfies the legal requirements. The legislation would also prohibit proceeding where an individual demonstrates refusal or resistance.
The debate highlights continuing divisions over patient autonomy, informed consent, protection of vulnerable individuals and the responsibilities of governments in regulating assisted dying.
The bill must still complete the remaining parliamentary stages before becoming law.