Canada acknowledges full tariff-free trade with U.S. may no longer be achievable

OTTAWA — Canada’s chief trade negotiator with the United States has acknowledged that restoring completely tariff-free trade may no longer be a realistic objective, reflecting a significant shift in Ottawa’s expectations as negotiations with Washington continue.

Janice Charette told the House of Commons Standing Committee on International Trade on November 17 that the Canadian government’s objective is now to secure the lowest possible tariffs on the smallest number of products.

Charette said the Trump administration has demonstrated little willingness to return to the broad tariff-free trading arrangements that previously governed much of the North American economy.

Her comments came during a parliamentary appearance alongside Canada–U.S. Trade Minister Dominic LeBlanc, who was questioned about the government’s handling of negotiations and the collapse of earlier discussions in August.

Although the Canada–United States–Mexico Agreement (CUSMA) continues to protect many Canadian exports, Washington has imposed sector-specific duties on industries including steel, aluminum and automobiles.

The uncertainty has placed significant pressure on Canadian manufacturers, particularly those operating within closely integrated North American supply chains.

The negotiations are further complicated by Washington’s decision not to renew CUSMA in its existing form, potentially subjecting the agreement to annual reviews and prolonging uncertainty for businesses.

For decades, relatively unrestricted access to the American market has been a cornerstone of Canada’s economic strategy. The latest developments suggest that Canadian businesses may have to prepare for a more protectionist trading environment, even if Ottawa ultimately succeeds in negotiating a new agreement.

The federal government continues to pursue both a negotiated settlement with Washington and the diversification of Canadian exports toward overseas markets.