Meta and Signal warn Canada’s proposed surveillance law could threaten encrypted services
- (0)

OTTAWA — Major technology companies are warning that proposed federal surveillance legislation could undermine digital privacy and potentially force some encrypted communication services to reconsider their operations in Canada.
Representatives of Meta, Signal and other technology organizations appeared before a Senate committee on November 16 to raise concerns about Bill C-22, the federal government’s proposed Lawful Access Act.
The legislation would expand the ability of police and intelligence agencies to obtain certain electronic information during investigations and require service providers to retain specified data under legally authorized procedures.
Critics argue that the proposed requirements could weaken the security of encrypted communications and expose Canadians to increased risks of unauthorized surveillance and cyberattacks.
Meta, which owns Facebook, Instagram and WhatsApp, warned that it could be forced to reconsider offering certain encrypted services in Canada if the legislation passes without further amendments.
Signal, whose messaging platform is built around end-to-end encryption, delivered an even stronger warning, saying it would not compromise its users’ security to comply with government requirements.
Apple and other major technology companies have also expressed reservations about the proposed legislation.
The Liberal government maintains that Bill C-22 is necessary to modernize investigative powers and combat serious crime in an increasingly digital environment.
Ottawa has already introduced amendments prohibiting companies from being compelled to create systemic security vulnerabilities and reducing the maximum required retention period for certain metadata from one year to six months.
Nevertheless, technology firms and privacy advocates argue that the changes do not sufficiently protect encrypted communications.
Privacy Commissioner Philippe Dufresne has also called for additional safeguards, particularly concerning the scope of personal information that authorities could obtain.
The dispute places the federal government at the centre of a broader debate over public safety, privacy rights and the limits of state access to digital communications.
Bill C-22 remains under Senate review.